Can One Source Repeated by Many Look Like Everyone Agrees? Yes.

BSF-0247 · Media & Persuasion

Can One Source Repeated by Many People Look Like Independent Consensus?

The Fact

Yes. Experiments on the “illusion of consensus” found that people do not always distinguish true consensus from multiple people repeating a claim that originated with one source, especially when source independence is unclear.

What This Means

Apparent agreement is strongest evidence when the agreeing sources reached their conclusions independently. Repetition of one origin can look like broader corroboration than it really is.

Sources

Connor Desai, S., Xie, B., & Hayes, B. K. (2022). “Getting to the source of the illusion of consensus.” Cognition 223:105023. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cognition.2022.105023

Evidence as of: 2022

Related Facts

← Search the Fact Bank

Scroll to Top